A number of robo-advisory startups have sprouted in Singapore in the last 2 years. They provide financial advice or portfolio management online with moderate to minimal human intervention in exchange for lower management fees. Most of the decision making is based on mathematical rules or algorithms.
I’ve been monitoring startups like AutoWealth, StashAway and Smartly who are competing in this space since they started and now, they have all obtained their respective MAS licences to operate (except Smartly who collaborated with VCG Partners Pte. Ltd. a MAS licensed fund manager in Singapore to manage your money).
With the right regulations in place, it’s a good opportunity to consider using robo-advisors to manage my investments.
If you’ve been following my blog, you would know that I’m a passive investor. I prefer to automate my investment workflow and have the investment portion of my monthly income go into investment without my involvement.
Unlike many others who like to monitor the stock market and read about global news, I prefer to focus on what I’m good at (my day job and side hustles) and grow my income.
While, I’m going to incur some expenses using robo-advisors, I’ve grown accustomed to the reality that if I will have to spend some money in order to save some time.
The most cost-effective way to invest is to purchase stocks and ETFs off the stock market on my own. By doing so, I can pay a one-time transaction fee that costs between $10-$40, and hold on to my investments for as long as I want. I only have to pay a final round of transaction fee when I decide to sell.
The most expensive way to depend on investment professionals like Financial Advisers and Investment Bankers to invest on your behalf because they will charge you at least 2-3% annual management fees each year to manage your portfolio.
Robo-advisors have a sweet spot in the middle where you pay for a small 0.2-1% Asset Under Management (AUM) fee each year to manage your portfolio. You get to enjoy that cost saving because robo-advisors have automated most of the investment activities and performs trades on your behalf based on mathematical rules or algorithms.
With a growing number of robo-advisory startups in Singapore, I went through all the websites of the key players in Singapore, namely Stashaway, Smartly and AutoWealth before making the decision to invest through AutoWealth’s robo-advisor platform.
In the end, I decided to start my robo-advisor investment journey with AutoWealth. Here’s why.
I intend to start investing through robo-advisors with a small investment capital ($5,000) and make monthly fund injections over the next few years, In my research, AutoWealth offered the lowest AUM fee (0.5% AUM + US$18 per year) among all the key players for my small investment portfolio.
If I were to invest a cool $100,000, the AUM fees of all the key players would be pretty much on par with one another.
For me, AutoWealth definitely wins this round easily!
This is going to be a long one so please bear with me here.
Both AutoWealth and Smartly have a investment quiz on their website that allows me to generate an investment portfolio by answering some questions.
Here’s the investment portfolio that AutoWealth recommended me when I opted for an aggressive retirement investment strategy.
When it comes to ETFs outside of Singapore, I consider myself as a rookie and I had to google to understand what the 6 ETFs were about. What I liked about AutoWealth’s portfolio recommendation is that they kept things really simple for rookies like me to understand by recommending just one ETF for each region.
For equities we have:
As for bonds, it’s just:
I completed a similar quiz on Smartly’s website with the same answers I used for AutoWealth and here’s the investment portfolio they recommended me.
Off the bat, I noticed that 1% of the money remains as cash. I presume that’s used to paid the 1% AUM fees. Okay, I can bear with that.
For equities, we have:
For bonds, it’s only:
I couldn’t find a similar investment quiz on Stashaway, so here’s a list of ETFs Stashaway have selected to invest for their clients. Because there wasn’t any investment portfolio recommendation that I could generate, I’m not going to comment much on Stashway in this article.
In a nutshell, we can see that:
Update: There were some typos in this article. I was referring to Smartly that was too concentrated in US and does not have exposure on emerging markets and China and not Stashaway.
Personally, I’m leaning towards AutoWealth in this aspect because I like clarity in what I’m investing in and I’d like some exposure to emerging markets.
I may be slightly biased here because I’ve only spoken to the folks from AutoWealth when I signed up for an account.
I was told that on top of getting the login details to my AutoWealth account, I would also receive login information to access my view-only Saxo Capital account. In a nutshell, AutoWealth is just the Money Manager and all the trading action takes place through Saxo Capital.
With my view-only account, I will also be able to see all the transactions that take place in my investment portfolio for that extra assurance. Therefore when AutoWealth tells me they invested my money into a specific portfolio, I can verify that it really did take place.
I’m not sure about you but I’m very comfortable with the level of transparency that AutoWealth is providing me with.
At this time of writing, I’ve already signed on the dotted line to open my account with AutoWealth and will be depositing my starting capital of $5,000 to start the account. I also intend to make regular monthly deposits into the account to continue to grow the portfolio.
The objective of this portfolio is to be able to provide long term care to my family in future. I’m going with a less aggressive 60-40 asset allocation for this portfolio and hopefully it will grow into a decent portfolio when I need to use the money.
To be honest, this new automated way of investing is quite refreshing because it takes another piece of investment task (rebalancing) away from my hands.
What do you think? I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comment section below.
Do you believe in dollar cost averaging or lump sum investment?
Over the past few years, I’m a firm believer on the former. But do I practice what I preach? That’s a whole different story.
While I’m consistently socking money away in my investment war chest, I found that I’ve not made a single transaction in my online brokerage account at all this year. *The horror!*
It’s not that I don’t have money to invest in my portfolio but the reality is that I’m still a novice when it comes to investing in the stock markets and the number 1 problem with newbies like me is that I keep trying to time the market.
Now this is a flaw that I recognize that I have and unfortunately I just can’t seem to help it! *sad face*
Because of the issues with the human (me), I decided to automate the investing process and take the human out of the process.
Automated investment is not a new thing in Singapore and 2 major banks, OCBC and DBS have already started offering this for some time now.
In fact, I’ve been using OCBC’s Blue Chip Investment Plan to invest my SRS monies in Nikko AM Singapore STI ETF for the past 2 years.
For my cash investments, I started using the POSB Invest-Saver to make monthly investments into
SPDR Straits Times Index ETF Nikko AM Singapore STI ETF and ABF Singapore Bond Index Fund. The process of applying for the Invest-Saver through the POSB iBanking platform was very easy since I already have a savings account with the bank.
Planned automated monthly investments in 2017:
Total automated investment in 2017: $27,300
Update: The comment from K is right. POSB Invest-Saver only invests in Nikko AM Singapore STI ETF and not SPDR Straits Times Index ETF. The article has been updated accordingly
Unfortunately, the monthly cash investment is still very small as bulk of my savings is still going towards funding my Cambodia SOHO property purchase.
Just because I’m doing it, doesn’t mean you should too.
If something can save you time, it’s probably going to cost you a little more money than doing it yourself.
I haven’t done the math but it’s very likely that using OCBC’s BCIP and POSB’s Invest-Saver to automate my investing process is most likely going to cost me a bit more than doing it manually on my online brokerage platform.
Weigh the pros and cons before making your decision. In my case, automating my investment process is definitely going to help align my investment portfolio with my investment objectives.
What are your thoughts on automating your investment process?
Unless you’ve been hiding in North Korea, you’ve probably know a little about the US presidential election that Donald Trump has been campaigning for a long time now.
Most of the information probably revolves around the crap he spews every time they put a mike in front of him.
What some of my friends consider to be the worst case scenario has happened today.
Donald Trump has won the presidential race and is now the President of the United States.
Without a doubt, everyone is going to be talking about the election results today. As the results surfaced in Google, there’s was five minutes of buzz in the office from colleagues discussing about the results. A mere five minutes! That’s right, everyone got back to work and the world continues to spin.
As a regular employee in a multinational corporation striving for FIRE (Financial Independence and Retiring Early), let me offer four contrarian reasons about why I think the impact of the US presidential election result isn’t going to have a big impact on your retirement strategies.
Donald Trump wants to move jobs back to the United States and kudos to him if he manages to do that and get more Americans employed.
Global companies set up shop in Singapore to establish a regional presence in Asia and their Singapore offices primarily functions as a regional hub to connect to countries in Asia. Nothing has changed.
There’s no compelling reason for your global office to shut down regional offices just because Donald Trump is President of the United States.
In fact, your regional office is probably more important now than ever because Asia may be the only region that is bringing in the revenue.
So continue working and squirrelling away your savings as planned for FIRE.
What you need to know is that if the government announces that the Singapore economy is down, it means that in reality, the Singapore economy has been heading south for quite a while.
Through my contacts, I’ve been hearing news about how many startups are dropping like flies, small and medium enterprises in Singapore are suffering and how it’s harder to generate new revenue nowadays.
If you haven’t been managing your expenses and making adjustments, it’s definitely a good time to start.
Europe is already in a mess. Donald Trump as the new President of the United States will bring a lot of uncertainty into the country.
Global investors will have nowhere to turn to except Asia and Singapore will have a high chance to be in the center of everything.
With more foreign investment potentially on the table, I’m confident that Singapore will be able to tide through this rough patch.
We’ve had two major events this year. Brexit and the US presidential elections. If you were swayed by emotions on hopes that Britain would remain in EU and Hillary Clinton would win the presidency, you would have gotten caught by market sentiments by making irrational decisions.
Personally, I’m comfortable with my current retirement strategy and don’t see the need to make any drastic changes just because of the US presidential election. There’s no reason to panic.
What are your thoughts about Donald Trump being the new President of the United States?